PicoBuddy

Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition

LLaura
Upper Elementary
Opinion / Argumentative
EN
2 min read
Image for Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition

Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition

Mauna Kea is a tall mountain on the Big Island of Hawaii. It's not just any mountain; it's a sacred place for many Native Hawaiians. They believe it's the home of their gods and ancestors. But, Mauna Kea is also one of the best places in the world to build telescopes because it has very clear and dark skies.

A Special Place for Telescopes

Scientists want to build more telescopes on Mauna Kea, including a really big one called the Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT). Telescopes help us see far into space and learn about stars, planets, and the universe. Mauna Kea is a great spot because it's high up, above most of the clouds and pollution that block our view. This means telescopes there can take very clear pictures of space.

Concerns and Arguments

However, building on Mauna Kea is causing a lot of debate. Many Native Hawaiians are worried about the desecration of their sacred mountain. They don't want more construction and equipment on a place they consider holy. Some people also worry about the environment. Building telescopes can damage the land and the unique plants and animals that live there.

On the other hand, supporters of the TMT say that it will bring lots of benefits. It could create jobs for people in Hawaii. More importantly, it could help us learn amazing new things about space. Scientists argue that they are being careful to protect the environment while they build.

Finding a Balance

So, what's the right thing to do? It's a tough question. How can we respect the beliefs and traditions of Native Hawaiians while also allowing scientists to explore the universe? Some people think we can find a way to build telescopes without harming the mountain. Others believe that no building should happen on Mauna Kea at all. It's a challenge to find a solution that everyone agrees on, but it's important to try and respect all points of view.

Listen to Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition

PicoBuddy read-aloud story

Checking access...
Glossary
Sacred:
Holy; connected to religion.
Desecration:
To damage or disrespect a holy place.
Telescope:
A tool to see far away things, like stars.
Loading reactions...
Loading quiz...
Loading practice questions...

Part of these collections

You Might Also Like

Image for A Path to a Safer Community: Why Oakwood Needs Protected Bike Lanes
Upper ElementaryPersuasive Letter • Opinion / Argumentative
Image for The Strength of Beauty: Why the Roman Arch Outshines Greek Temples
Upper ElementaryOpinion Piece • Opinion / Argumentative

About this opinion / argumentative passage for Upper Elementary

“Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition” is a opinion / argumentative reading passage about Environmental Science, written for Upper Elementary. It takes about 2 minutes to read (329 words) and comes with an interactive quiz and a printable worksheet with comprehension questions and an answer key.

Is this passage free?

Yes. You can read “Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition” online for free and download a printable PDF worksheet with comprehension questions and an answer key.

What reading level is “Mauna Kea: Telescope vs. Tradition”?

It’s written for Upper Elementary — a opinion / argumentative text about Environmental Science, about a 2-minute read (329 words).

What’s included with this passage?

An illustrated reading passage, a glossary of key terms, comprehension questions with an answer key, and an interactive quiz.

Can I adapt it for my students?

Yes. With a free account you can remix it to a different grade level or translate it to another language in one click.