Two Plans, One Garden


Narrator: On Monday morning, two sketches lay on a classroom table. Maya and Luis had been asked to design a small garden for their class project.
Maya: My sketch has rows of flowers around a bench. People could sit there and enjoy the colors. She slid her drawing toward Luis.
Luis: Mine has vegetables in raised beds. We could grow lettuce and tomatoes and share what we harvest.
Maya: But a vegetable garden might look messy. I want our project to make the schoolyard beautiful.
Luis: And I want it to be useful. Flowers are nice, but you can't make a salad with them.
Narrator: Maya crossed her arms. Luis pulled his sketch closer. For a moment, neither of them spoke.
Maya: Maybe we should ask the class to vote. Then we can use the winning plan.
Luis: I guess so. But I spent all weekend drawing mine.
Maya: I worked hard on mine, too.
Narrator: The garden plans were due that afternoon. Their teacher had given each pair a space about as wide as a classroom door and twice as long. There was room for plants, but not for two separate gardens and a bench.
Luis: What if we look at the space before we decide? Maybe the drawings make it seem bigger than it is.
- sketches:
- quick drawings that show ideas
- harvest:
- the food gathered after it has grown
- separate:
- kept apart from one another
- patch:
- a small area of ground
- shadow:
- a dark area made when something blocks light
- narrow:
- not wide
- recognized:
- noticed or identified something familiar
You Might Also Like
About this reader's theater passage for Upper Elementary
“Two Plans, One Garden” is a reader's theater reading passage about Respect across differences, written for Upper Elementary. It takes about 4 minutes to read (587 words) and comes with an interactive quiz and a printable worksheet with comprehension questions and an answer key.


