Two Voices on Ratification

PicoBuddy8th GradeExplanatory Article6 min read928 words
Image for Two Voices on Ratification

Two pamphlet-style papers lie side by side on a table: one argues that a large republic can protect liberty, while the other warns that its size may put liberty at risk. During the debate over the United States Constitution, arguments like these appeared in newspapers and circulated among readers. Americans were deciding whether to ratify, or approve, a new plan of government. The outcome would shape who held power and how that power could be controlled.

A new plan under debate

In 1787, delegates meeting in Philadelphia wrote the Constitution to replace the Articles of Confederation. Under the Articles, the national government had limited powers. For example, Congress could request money from the states, but it could not directly tax people to raise revenue. Supporters of a stronger national government believed these limits made it difficult to solve shared problems.

The proposed Constitution would give Congress the power to tax, regulate trade, and make laws within its assigned authority. It would also create an executive branch headed by a president and a federal court system. Before the plan could take effect, however, at least nine states had to approve it through special conventions.

Glossary
revenue:
Money collected by a government to pay for its activities.
regulate:
To control an activity by making and enforcing rules.
authority:
The legal power or right to act.
circulated:
Passed from person to person or place to place.
dominate:
To control or have power over others.
accountable:
Required to answer for decisions and actions.
legislature:
A group of people who make laws.
explicit:
Clearly stated rather than left to be guessed.

One passage, many ways to practice

Reading-skill questions, word work and writing prompts — all built from this text.

Also available in other languages.
  • Main Idea

    Identify the central idea and explain how important details develop it.

  • Context Clues

    Use clues in the passage to work out what words mean. A separate printable Vocabulary worksheet is also available.

  • Summarize

    Select, organize, and restate the most important information without adding opinion.

  • Purpose

    Analyze what the author aims to do and how choices serve audience and purpose.

  • Structure

    Analyze how sections and organizational choices build the text's ideas or effects.

  • Fact & Opinion

    Distinguish verifiable statements from judgments, beliefs, and preferences in context.

  • Claims & Evidence

    Trace and evaluate how claims are supported by reasons and evidence.

  • Vocabulary

    Practice words from the passage with a printable worksheet.

  • Writing Prompts

    Use the passage as a springboard for short written responses, from personal reflection to evidence-based arguments.

  • Fix the Sentence

    Practice editing sentences drawn from this passage with a printable worksheet.

Ready to use this passage in class?

Start free with the Mixed worksheet and 3 PDF downloads each week. Focused skill sets depend on plan.

Sign up with emailLog in

Preview questions from this passageShow
  1. 1Why did supporters of a stronger national government want to replace the Articles of Confederation?
  2. 2How did Madison think a large republic could limit the danger of a harmful majority?

Where this passage belongs

You Might Also Like

Image for Freedom on Paper and in Daily Life
8th GradeExplanatory Article • Informational
Image for From Selma to the Voting Rights Act
8th GradeExplanatory Article • Informational

About this explanatory article passage for 8th Grade

“Two Voices on Ratification” is a explanatory article reading passage about Constitutional ratification, written for 8th Grade. It takes about 6 minutes to read (928 words) and comes with an interactive quiz and a printable worksheet with comprehension questions and an answer key.

Is this passage free?

Yes. With a free account, you can read “Two Voices on Ratification” online and download a printable PDF worksheet with comprehension questions and an answer key.

What reading level is “Two Voices on Ratification”?

It’s written for 8th Grade — a explanatory article text about Constitutional ratification, about a 6-minute read (928 words).

What’s included with this passage?

An illustrated reading passage, a glossary of key terms, comprehension questions with an answer key, and an interactive quiz.

Can I adapt it for my students?

Yes. Remix is included with Pro and Max for adapting it to another grade level or language.